The last few years have taught me to just trust Kenny Williams. He made some questionable decisions in
2005, and the White Sox ended up winning the World Series.
There's just one problem with that theory.
Back in 2003, after making some brilliant deadline deals that got the Cubs to within five outs of reaching the World Series, Cubs fans felt the same way about Jim Hendry.
We all know how they feel about him now.
So, excuse me if I'm a little concerned about the state of the White Sox right now, particularly after a peculiar offseason. Dealing Freddy Garcia for minor-leaguers to open a spot for Brandon McCarthy, and then dealing McCarthy for more minor-leaguers left me scratching my head.
Williams' reasoning is that the money pitchers command these days is ridiculous (it is, no argument there), and that the White Sox need to stockpile young arms.
The problem is, now Williams seems to be of the opinion that he can let anybody he wants go and just replace them.
Take, for instance, his stance on Tadahito Iguchi, Mark Buehrle, and Jermaine Dye, three free-agents-to-be at season's end:
The White Sox' general manager continued to be brutally honest about the futures of free agents-to-be Mark Buehrle, Jermaine Dye and Tadahito Iguchi, reiterating what he told the Sun-Times on Saturday about letting the three walk into free agency.
''You never say never, but I don't foresee it, no,'' Williams responded when asked if he thought a deal could be struck during the season with any of the three. ''There comes a point where you have to take a step back before taking two steps forward, and we're at that point with all of these contracts.''
Williams said the only reason it is still a hot topic in camp is because he's still being asked about it. While that likely won't stop, Williams did say he plans on giving out the same rehearsed answer very soon.
''You try answering [the media] questions as openly and honestly as possible and give the people the most accurate information,'' Williams said. ''I hope the questions stop, but as long as people continue to ask, I'll continue to answer.
''At this point, it's probably going to be the same answer from here on out, where we'll continue to take a long look at it. If the agents of the respective players want to bring something to the table for us to look at, we'll do that. But in our assessment, it seems everyone has agreed to look at this in the offseason and make the best determination on where we're going to go then. The smartest thing to do for both the player and the club is to wait until the end of the season.''
I think it's pretty obvious that Buehrle is gone at season's end. After a sub-par season in 2006, and then popping up on the internet in his Cardinals gear during the World Series, he's done little to endear himself to Williams and the White Sox brass lately.
This season is kind of a no-win situation for Buehrle and the White Sox. If he has another bad season, the Sox won't want to re-sign him. If he returns to the All-Star form of 2005, he'll command too much money on the free-agent market, and the Sox won't re-sign him.
As far as Dye, I'm not sure what's going to happen. If Dye has another season like 2006 (.315 44HR 120RBI) he'll probably price himself out of the range the Sox are willing to go for an outfielder that will turn 34 in 2008.